Car crashes, slip-and-fall incidents, and other serious accidents happen every day across Bloomington-Normal and McLean County. Whether your accident occurred on Veterans Parkway, a rural road near LeRoy, or outside a store in Downtown Bloomington, you’ll likely have to deal with an insurance company.
Avoiding Common Insurance Mistakes
While there are some universal mistakes accident victims make, Illinois law — and the way local claims are handled — adds extra layers of complexity. Here’s what you need to know to keep your case strong in Central Illinois.
A Quick Look at the 5 Common Mistakes
Before diving into Illinois-specific guidance, here’s a quick summary of the pitfalls accident victims should avoid:
- Saying too much to the insurance company — Casual comments can be twisted into admissions of fault.
- Agreeing to a recorded statement without advice — Once recorded, your words can be used against you.
- Accepting an early settlement offer — First offers rarely account for all losses, especially future care.
- Delaying or skipping medical care — Gaps in treatment weaken your claim.
- Failing to document everything — Photos, bills, and records are critical to proving damages.
Now, let’s explore what these mean when you’re pursuing a claim right here in Illinois — especially in Bloomington-Normal and surrounding towns.
Illinois’ Modified Comparative Negligence Law
Under 735 ILCS 5/2-1116, Illinois follows a modified comparative negligence rule. This means you can still recover damages if you’re less than 50% at fault, but your award is reduced by your percentage of fault.
Local Insight: In McLean County, accident reports from the Bloomington or Normal Police Departments — or the McLean County Sheriff’s Office for rural areas — often play a key role in determining fault. The statements you give to insurance adjusters could end up being compared to what’s in the police report. If there’s inconsistency, insurers will use it to shift more blame your way.
Dealing with Medical Treatment in Central Illinois
Insurance companies frequently argue that a delay in treatment means you weren’t really hurt. This is especially risky in rural parts of McLean County where you might not have immediate access to a hospital.
Local Tip: OSF St. Joseph Medical Center and Carle BroMenn Medical Center in Normal are the two primary trauma care facilities. If your accident happens far from these, document any reason for delays (e.g., no urgent care open nearby, long ambulance transport time). This protects you from claims that you “waited too long” to seek help.
Local Settlement Dynamics and Insurance Tactics
In McLean County, adjusters for accidents on I-55, I-74, and Route 9 often represent national carriers but work with local claims offices. We see a pattern: they offer quick settlements before the injured person has completed treatment — hoping you’ll take the check before you know the full cost of recovery.
Why It Matters: Once you sign a settlement release in Illinois, your case is closed forever — even if you later discover additional injuries or expenses. The Illinois courts will not reopen the claim.
The Importance of Documentation for McLean County Claims
If your case ends up in the McLean County Circuit Court, judges and juries will expect clear, consistent evidence. That means your accident scene photos, injury progression images, and medical records from local providers (such as OSF PromptCare or Carle Convenient Care) must be well organized.
Pro Tip: Keep a written injury diary noting how your injuries impact daily life in Bloomington-Normal. This personal account can carry weight with a jury because it paints a picture beyond the bills and reports.
How Local Legal Help Makes the Difference
McLean County cases are subject to Illinois statutes, but local procedures matter. For example:
- Knowing how local judges handle scheduling orders can affect the pace of your case.
- Being familiar with regional medical providers means your lawyer knows where to get complete, accurate records quickly.
- Local knowledge of high-accident intersections (e.g., Towanda Avenue & Empire Street) can strengthen an argument about foreseeability and negligence.
Meet Dustin Koth — Your Local Injury Advocate
Attorney Dustin Koth of Koth Gregory & Nieminski has deep roots in Bloomington-Normal and years of experience representing accident victims across McLean County. He understands the tactics insurance companies use here and how to counter them effectively. Whether you’re from Downs, Hudson, LeRoy, or right in Bloomington, Dustin offers the strategic guidance and personal attention you need.
Real Client Story
“I am thankful to be alive and that Dustin Koth took my case ensuring the insurance company fairly resolved my settlement.”
— M. H., Personal Injury Client
This is a real photo of our personal injury client’s truck at the scene of the car accident. Our client was lucky to be alive and wisely took this photo before being taken away by first responders.
By taking photos at the scene and avoiding the other common mistakes mentioned in this article, our client’s case was set up for success. We quickly got him a good settlement and avoided the delay tactics insurance companies often play.
Take Action Today
If you or someone you love has been injured in Bloomington-Normal or anywhere in McLean County, don’t risk your claim by going it alone.
Contact Koth Gregory & Nieminski for a free consultation. We’ll guide you through Illinois law, protect your rights, and fight for the full compensation you deserve.
Frequently Asked Questions About Injury Claims in McLean County
How does Illinois comparative negligence affect my injury claim?
Illinois follows a modified comparative negligence rule, meaning you can recover compensation as long as you are less than 50% at fault. However, your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault. Insurance companies in McLean County often use statements and police reports to try to shift blame and reduce payouts.
Should I give a recorded statement to an insurance adjuster in Illinois?
You are not required to give a recorded statement to the other party’s insurance company. In Illinois injury claims, recorded statements are frequently used to find inconsistencies and argue comparative fault, especially when compared to Bloomington or Normal police reports.
Can delaying medical treatment hurt my injury claim in McLean County?
Yes. Delaying medical care can weaken your claim by allowing insurers to argue your injuries were not serious or unrelated to the accident. This is a common tactic in McLean County cases, particularly when treatment does not begin promptly at facilities like OSF St. Joseph or Carle BroMenn.
Why are early settlement offers risky under Illinois law?
Once you sign a settlement release in Illinois, your claim is permanently closed—even if new injuries or expenses arise. Insurance companies handling McLean County accidents often push early offers before treatment is complete to limit their financial exposure.
What documentation is most important for a McLean County injury case?
Strong injury claims rely on photos of the accident scene, medical records from local providers, proof of lost wages, and documentation showing how injuries affect daily life. If your case reaches the McLean County Circuit Court, clear and organized evidence is critical.
When should I contact a local personal injury lawyer after an accident?
You should contact a McLean County personal injury lawyer as soon as possible after an accident—especially before giving statements or accepting a settlement. Early legal guidance helps protect your rights and prevents mistakes that insurance companies commonly exploit.
Revised: December 16, 2025
Related Article
5 Costly Insurance Company Mistakes to Avoid After an Accident.
Disclaimer:
The intent of this Article is to provide general information. It should not be construed as legal advice. The Law Firm of Koth, Gregory & Nieminski, P.C. (KGN) does not represent or guarantee that the information in this Article is current.
The information is provided as is without any representation or warranty as to whether the information is current, applicability, reliability, merchantability, fitness, non-infringement, result, or any other matter. The existence of the Article, receipt of its information, and/or comments/questions do NOT create an attorney-client relationship between KGN or any of its attorneys.
Please do not send KGN any confidential material or information. Viewers of this Article should NOT act/refrain from acting based on information contained in this Article and KGN expressly disclaims all liability for actions/failures to act based on this Article.